Middle Trinity Directors Hears Remarks from Rep. Sid Miller

By LAURA KESTNER, Editor

State Representative Sid Miller addressed the board of directors at the most recent meeting of the Middle Trinity Groundwater Conservation District board of directors, Thursday, July 3, 2008, in Dublin.

Present and participating were board members Rodney Stephens, Fred Parker, Jerry Fronterhouse, George Bingham and Ed Dittfurth, MTGCD general manager Joe Cooper, and Wes Burris, field tech. Not present was board member Jerry Hinshaw, and Sharon Mainord, administrative assistant.

“Basically, I hadn’t had a chance to drop by during a meeting,” Sid Miller said, “and I just wanted to stop in. It’s the interim state of the legislature, we’ll be meeting again in January, so I’m trying to get my legislative package together. And I wanted to bump some ideas off of you. I know we’ve had some ongoing problems with disposal wells, permitting and what-not and I was going to let y’all know what I’m thinking about doing, and get your input.”

Miller then discussed his efforts to “shore up the notification process” for oil and gas injection wells.
“Right now when they apply for a permit, they have to do a public notice,” Miller said. “But basically, they can just publish in any newspaper they want to. First problem we had was with a well down in Hico, right near the city limits, and they published the notice in the Hamilton paper, but not in the Hico paper. Then we had one recently that published in the Fort Worth Star Telegram instead of in the Dublin paper.”

Miller’s planned changes include requirements that would call for notices to be printed in the paper in the closest proximity to the well-site.

“And they’d have to publish the notice in the largest circulation newspaper in the county too,” Miller said. “Also, it would require them to give notice to any adjoining land owner, or tenant. I’m going to try and go with that. It would also require notice to all county commissioners, county judges, and elected officials, including water district board members -- so that everyone could know what was going on.”

Miller then asked for any comments from the directors.

“I support the oil and gas initiative on the waste injection wells,” Cooper said. “The fear that people have...the concerns are, that we’re going to get the oil and gas waste injection that produce salt water from all those places adjacent to us, in the Barnett Shale, that are incorporated, that can pass rules disallowing it. So...people feel like we’re going to get a lot of stuff brought into our counties. And really, the over-riding concern, and the catalyst for some activists, is that they don’t feel like, whether it’s true or not, that the Railroad Commission is doing due diligence with oversight on construction of the wells.”

Cooper added that he believed that agency to be understaffed. “Those kind of concerns are what bother people,” he said, adding that “Anything that could be done would be good.”

“I think a lot of the time the Railroad Commission is doing what it’s supposed to, but it’s just maybe losing track of it,” Cooper said. “When people ask for documentation of things that are required by law and they can’t get it, then their first assumption is, ‘that’s because it doesn’t exist, it wasn’t done’ and it may have been done.”

Cooper said that there was a solution to all the problems.

“What we really need..to stop all these problems, is if we could just require the oil and gas waste injection wells be placed outside the boundaries of our state’s mapped aquifers,” Cooper said. “There’s lots of territory that doesn’t have any groundwater. We wouldn’t have to worry about whether they’re constructed right to start with. The problem is, the oil and gas industry is certainly going to buck up, because it’s going to cost them a little more, to haul it a little further. And till the law makes them do it, they’re not going to do it of their own free will.”

Cooper then spoke briefly regarding a problem encountered by the Rolling Plains Groundwater District.
“Just recently, the Rolling Plains Groundwater District lost in appeals court, a case against the City of Aspermont,” Cooper said. “As you know, when our district was founded, people here were concerned about water marketing -- keeping their water here and not letting people come in and buy it and sell it. So we adopted rules that tried to dissuade that practice. One of them, is an export fee. Well, Rolling Plains had an export fee, and Aspermont came into their groundwater district...(to export water) and for the first several months they paid the prescribed export fees, and then they decided to just stop paying it, and it went to court. The courts have ruled that the City of Aspermont is immune to the rules of the groundwater conservation district.”

Cooper then mentioned concerns about similar potential problems with MTGCD.

“Our biggest user is the City of Stephenville,” Cooper said. “If this district couldn’t regulate its biggest user, for the benefit of the aquifer and everybody else that uses water in that aquifer, we might as well go home. So we need to get that fixed -- to make sure we’re able to treat everybody the same. When you’re talking about water, we need to treat everybody the same.”

Miller made notes throughout Cooper’s comments, and at the conclusion noted that the problems with Rolling Plains and Aspermont was probably had nothing to do with the water code, and everything to do with the government code, and might be difficult to change.

“But one of the promising things on this waste water disposal, is the potential for not injecting any of it period,” Miller said.

“There’s been a lot of research, and there are some new innovations,” Miller said. “Over in east Texas, there’s a machine, I don’t know exactly how to describe it...but they can take that truck load of salt water and actually recover four or five barrels of oil out of it -- and purify about 80 percent of the water, and then you only have about 15 or 20 percent of it that has to be hauled off.”

Miller said it was sort of “a reverse osmosis process.” He added that he believes the oil and gas industry as a whole, because of the pressures from the water districts and the public, would begin to move towards such innovations. He then noted that the rising cost of fuel should also make such alternative disposal methods appealing to the industry.

During the Manager’s Report, Cooper updated the directors on recent discussions with Coryell County representatives regarding possible consolidation with MTGCD, including potential difficulties with their election or petition process.

Cooper also noted that there were “now 14,686 wells in the database.”

“We’re making great progress on that,” Cooper said. “The lady who’s working for us is just doing a super job, and I expect we’ll be through with this process by the end of August.”

Cooper also provided directors with an update on progress with the new building site (in Stephenville) for MTGCD headquarters. “He (the realtor) indicated he was in the process of working with the landowner and the Stephenville Planning and Zoning committee to re-plat that piece of property,” Cooper said, “so that we could move towards closing on it.”

In other business, board members:

• Approved and ratified the payment of bills.

• Reviewed the income/expense comparison.

• Reviewed the quarterly report on investments.

During the Quarterly Drought Assessment, Cooper noted that the Palmer Drought Severity Index indicated that the area had entered a dry spell.

“The prior three quarters have been normal, very wet, and very wet, respectively,” Cooper said. “And the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration indicates that those conditions will persist or worsen through the end of September. That’s not the best outlook we’d like to have, but that’s the best that science has got for us.”